OPEN 6 a.m. – 6 p.m. DAILY
14 S. Beaver St. | Flagstaff, AZ | 928-774-2243

Home  |  Contact
Macys Bakery Special Orders

Planning an event? Whether it’s a birthday, office party, graduation, baby shower, office meeting, wedding or just for the heck of it; Macy’s is here to help!

All special orders are handmade from scratch using quality ingredients. Macy’s also understands the gluten-free needs of many Flagstaff residents, so many of our items altered to accommodate. We do however, require 48 hours of notice to prepare for all cakes, cheesecakes, pies and other specialty items. Cookies, quick breads and breakfast pastries require 24 hours notice. Please call 928-774-2243 for pricing.

2-Layer CAKES:

- Chocolate* - Chocolate Hazelnut*
- Chocolate Zucchini* - Chocolate Espresso*
- Vanilla - Carrot*
- Spice* - Coconut*
- Yellow
- Lemon - Orange
- Zucchini

Single layer cakes CANNOT be filled.


Italian Wedding – German Chocolate – Boston Cream Pie – Tres Leches

Cake Sizes: 8", 10", 12", 14", 1/2 Sheet


 -Whipped Cream

-Cream Cheese*: Vanilla, Chocolate, Orange, Lemon, Coconut, Espresso, Spice, Strawberry, Raspberry, Blackberry

-Buttercream*: Vanilla, Chocolate, Orange, Lemon, Coconut, Espresso, Spice, Strawberry, Raspberry, Blackberry

* Can be made dairy-free, but not vegan, as powdered sugar is not considered vegan.


-Mocha Mousse, White Chocolate Mousse, Bavarian Cream, Lemon Curd, Raspberry, Strawberry, Peach, Blackberry, Blueberry, Mango



Gluten Free

Fresh Fruit

PIES: (All pies are 8")

*Cream pies are made with graham cracker crusts and topped with whipped cream.

Banana Cream - Coconut Cream - Key Lime Cream - Chocolate Cream

Pumpkin (Can be made vegan with graham, pastry or oat nut crust.)

Pecan (pastry crust)

Chocolate Pecan (pastry crust)

Fruit (double crusted) (Can be made vegan.)
Apple - Strawberry - Blueberry - Blackberry - Cherry - Peach - Very Berry


8" (feeds 8-12) 10" (feeds 10-20)

Plain - Lemon - Chocolate - Blueberry - Pumpkin - Strawberry - Raspberry White Chocolate - Chocolate Chip - Black & White - Chocolate Hazelnut Espresso - Peanut Butter - Cherry - Lemon Raspberry


Chocolate Chip - Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip - Peanut Butter* - Oatmeal Raisin* - Chewy Molasses* - Cranberry White Chocolate Chip - Pumpkin Pecan White Chocolate Chip - Jam Dots (vegan/wheat free) - Ginger Bread - Sugar - No Bake (Peanut Butter/Chocolate - vegan/wheat free) - Lemon Crescents...other options available


- Ask about flavor options or create your own


- Ask about flavor options or create your own

Please call 928-774-2243 for pricing.


News Feed

  • Introduction

    Welcome to Macy's Coffee House Blog! 

    Here, I'll be posting updates and information on everything going on at Macy's. This is also a space where you can leave comments, questions and just keep in touch. We look forward to hearing from you!

  • A New Look for a New Year

    Macy’s is dedicated to preserving its home-town feel. We also strive to keep up with the times. We have revamped and updated our website to create a more informative and interactive feel, and we are going green wherever possible. We hope you enjoy our story.


Macy's Events Flagstaff


"It’s simply the best coffee I’ve ever had, and I have had coffee all over the world! -- Lisa


"No trip to Flagstaff would be complete without a trip to Macy's.” -- Scott Katz


Site Design by Roxanna Brock McDade & Malena Lou